Monday, December 11, 2006

They fuck you up

They fuck you up, your mum and dad.
They may not mean to, but they do.
They fill you with the faults they had
And add some extra, just for you.

But they were fucked up in their turn
By fools in old-style hats and coats,
Who half the time were soppy-stern
And half at one another's throats.

Man hands on misery to man.
It deepens like a coastal shelf.
Get out as early as you can,
And don't have any kids yourself.


Larkin's poem is so true. And Christmas is an odd time, because you get letters and cards from people you haven't heard from for a long time. Like from my dad. My dad (who lives in London), is very peculiar. For one thing he is under the impression that we have a 'normal' father-daughter relationship. I.e. he writes to me sometimes like we have a whole history of jolly outings and family holidays and wonderful warm memories, when we don't, or at most, maybe a tiny sprinkle of them.

My mum and he dated for a year or so when he was a student at London University in 1970, and she was working as an au pair (she's Austrian). Anyway, she got pregnant, he freaked out. She had the baby (me), he didn't want to know. But in any case, I did see him now and again while I was a child and I was quite fond of him. Although mostly I remember going to visit him in his flat which was full of dusty wine bottles, and him being at a loss as to how to entertain me, which is quite endearing really. But visiting him wasn't so bad, it wasn't awful, although he did cook some weird meals like boiled fish.

But the whole situation was very antagonistic between my mother and him, and eventually she said he couldn't see me any more (not that I think he particularly cared one way or the other). And even though he is an eccentric composer who is totally self-centred and has really never done a thing for me (the only thing he has ever done was let me store my belongings in the basement of his house when I moved to the States). Even though he has really ever expressed his love for me, I still love him, and that is the strange thing about life. Even though the relationship is totally non-existent in any concrete way, it still moves me when he writes in his letter:

"I often go through or past Regent's Park, and I remember so well you playing there when you were about 6 or 7. Do you remember hunting for the Easter eggs? I do. I also remember playing in the sandpit."

You can never not love your parents. Well, unless they did something really awful. But they do fuck you up, they may not mean to but they do. Or at least mine did. Only at some point you have to stop blaming your mum and dad and start defining yourself, don't you? But it's hard, I guess. When you don't really have a dad, I think in some way, some totally irrational way, you sometimes think you are unlovable. And all the love from your mum, from friends and boyfriends and then your husband and kids, and all the rest, I don't think it ever compensates. And you think, why should it matter, that he didn't at least try to love me? And then you understand that maybe he did try, but couldn't manage it. Because, I think that despite everything, it is there. He does love me somewhere, buried deep. Maybe that is all that matters.

13 comments:

mad muthas said...

typos that changed history, part one: they tuck you up, your mum and dad ...

Leezer said...

Oh Emma:
Goddamn it I'm at work and I'm reading this and crying! You need to post a warning: THIS MAY MAKE YOU CRY AT WORK!!!!

I agree. At some point, it's necessary to accept love - not in the way that we want to receive it - but in the way it is given, such as it may be.

This is what it means to be a grownup, I think.

Tickersoid said...

I sacrificed so much of my life for my kids and still managed to fuck them up.

We talked about it at length and concluded it was close to the best we could hope for under the circumstances.

la fille mariƩe said...

Beautifully written, Emma.

Some fathers, fathers of a certain generation, have a lot to answer for. Those who were present physically were so often emotionally absent. Either way, daughters paid by feeling that they must always earn love, that expressing emotion is unacceptable, or that they are just plain unloveable.

And then, one day, Emma, your dad is gone for good, and there's no way to go back and fix things. If I had it to do again, I would forgive more, and accept that my father's choices and deficiencies were his, not mine.

deb said...

I think fathers are so important to women because they are the first men to love us. How well they do that varies widely.
My own parents were married but we always wished they weren't, they were unhappy most of their lives it seemed and my father was angry and depressed for most of my life.
Before he died I was able to understand that he'd done his best and I forgave him. We all do our best I think, I'm sure my grandparents did their best as well. My grandmother was an alcoholic, so I kind of doubt her best included hugs and kisses and a stable home for my dad. I still wish he'd been different though, I wish he'd been the kind of dad you could talk to. There, made myself cry.

meva said...

It's a shame that some parents want to hurt each other, because they end up hurting their children the most.

Your father wouldn't write to you if he didn't love you.

Janet a.k.a. "Wonder Mom" said...

And that is my fear. That I'll do the fucking up eventually...

Wonderful post Emma.

Kira said...

loving, and loving well, i suppose are two different things. I guess he does the best he can.

kimba said...

my mother is the problem parent.. all of us kids in the family have talked it over for years.. all the ways she's fucked us up (my sister even stood up at the Christmas table one year and announced to the family that she was clinically depressed.. suicidal.. and it was all mum's fault..)Merry Christmas!

Mum is a fuck up - she's a child at times and has dodgey relationships.. but like all of us - she's doing what she can with the resources she has.. I can understand it all when I think of that.. she's not trying to fuck us up.. she does.. but she's not trying to..

It's funny (or not) how there are similar responses from your commenters.. we all know the pain - we have different stories.. but same pain..

CrankMama said...

They do indeed.. and that's what so scary about being a parent. We're one of "them" now.

CrankMama said...

And, BTW, if ever there were a cool chic who DESERVED a great dad, it's you.

Miss Devylish said...

I would agree w/ Leezer - Hi, warn a girl won't you?

I always wished we could be the Cleaver family or something more normal than we were and was sure we were the only family who fought like we did. I often felt that I could see thru their arguments about nothing at all important and what made me so defiant was the constant yelling back that I wasn't stupid.. no matter what they said. My father was angry and I think Mom was angry cuz she didn't love him like she thought she would.. or something. They both drank often and were pretty miserable off and on together. A lot of raised hands and voices - verbal abuse, but it made me stronger I suppose.

By the time my dad died, I'd given up fighting as much cuz I realized the problems were always w/in my parents' self esteem and their parents were abusive when they were young. It was a strange cycle. My parents were mellow compared to my grandparents. And I forgave my dad as much as possible tho I watched it take a toll on my mom, even tho she was far from perfect and could teach guilt trips 101 in a pinch (which I told her quite often).

It's amazing what age can do tho - now that she's remarried, she's a different and happier person and actually, a better mom. And I have no doubt my dad loved me, tho he always seemed angry, but he did do the best he could.

hugs to you girl.. xoxo

Paige said...

Having had my own issues with my own father, I've come back to this post several times this week, feeling the same exact things you've said here and yet...still unable to utter more than a sniffly "they fuck you up indeed they do." As many times as I've tried to shake myself and say "You're an adult Paige, just deal with it and define yourself on your own terms." there are still those times when you'd like that father to...BE there in more than just name. My father couldn't and so...it is what it is.